Skip to content
Pause slideshow
Play slideshow
Order by Dec 14 for Christmas Delivery (Standard Shipping)
Hassle-free returns. 30-day postage paid returns
$55+ ORDERS SHIP FREE
Free Shipping on Orders $55+ After Discounts
Mixed Up Foods
HOLIDAYS
Shop
Find Near You
Online
All products
Small Jars
Regular Jars
Glass Jars
Bulk Tubs
Bundles & Deals
Jams
Gift Cards
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Bliss" - Maple, Walnut & Pecan Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
About
Our Story
Contact
Events
Recipes
Reviews
Earn
Rewards
Give $5, Get $5
Affiliate Program
Search
Account
0
Cart
.
.
.
Site navigation
Close
Search
Search
Cancel
Goes great with
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Bliss" - Maple, Walnut & Pecan Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Creemee" - Vermont Maple, Cashew, and Pecan Nut Butter with Vanilla Bean - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Mud Season" - Crunchy Cacao Nib & Coffee Nut Butter - 7.5 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"The New Favorite" - Almond, Pecan, and Cashew Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Add order note
Close
Your cart is currently empty.
HOLIDAYS
icon-chevron
Shop
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Shop
View all
icon-chevron
Find Near You
icon-chevron
Online
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Online
View all
icon-chevron
All products
icon-chevron
Small Jars
icon-chevron
Regular Jars
icon-chevron
Glass Jars
icon-chevron
Bulk Tubs
icon-chevron
Bundles & Deals
icon-chevron
Jams
icon-chevron
Gift Cards
icon-chevron
About
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
About
Our Story
icon-chevron
Contact
icon-chevron
Events
icon-chevron
Recipes
icon-chevron
Reviews
icon-chevron
Earn
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Earn
Rewards
icon-chevron
Give $5, Get $5
icon-chevron
Affiliate Program
icon-chevron
Recipes
Chocolate
Coffee
Dates
Desserts
Snacks
Coffee Nut Butter Stuffed Dates
May 13, 2025
Desserts
Sweet
Vegan
Vegan Chocolate Banana Ice Cream
Aug 05, 2024
Desserts
Snacks
Chocolate Coated Ice Cream Bites
Jun 18, 2023
Desserts
Nut Butter-Waffle No-Churn Ice Cream
Jun 07, 2023
Desserts
Snacks
Vegan Egg Nog Bites
Dec 24, 2022
Desserts
Walnut Butter Cheesecake With Raspberry Swirl
Feb 12, 2022
Desserts
Snacks
Mixed Nut Butter & Jelly Bars
Oct 02, 2020
Desserts
Edible Cookie Dough
Aug 09, 2020
Desserts
Flourless Chocolate Chip Cookies
Jun 26, 2020
Explore more
Beverages
Breakfast
Chocolate
Coffee
Condiments & Dressings
Dates
Dessert
Desserts
Dips & Spreads
Gluten Free
No Bake
Savory
Sides
Snacks
Sweet
Vegan
"Close (esc)"
icon-chevron
"Close (esc)"
Recipes
