Craft Nut & Seed Butter

Made from Tree Nuts (Not Peanuts!) & Minimally-Processed Ingredients.
Healthy & delicious nut butter for every occasion.
Maple Creemee Vermont Nut Butter


No Palm Oil Icon


Non GMO icon


No Refined Sugars icon


Gluten Free icon


Vegan icon


Dairy Free Icon


Maple Creemee - Maple, cashew, pecan nut butter
Maple Creemee nut butter with maple,cashew, and pecan nuts and The High Bar nut butter with almond, pecan, and walnuts.

#What we do


We make craft nut and seed butter from uncommon blends of minimally processed ingredients. Our products are free from palm oil, refined oils, refined sugars, gluten, dairy, GMOs, flavorings, artificial preservatives, and other additives. Across our nut butters, we use at least two of the following types of nuts: almonds, pecans, cashews, and walnuts, not peanuts!
  • Simple and quality ingredients

  • A nut flavor for every occasion

  • Great source of healthy fats and protein

People love MIXED UP

Excellent on toast or celery

"Excellent on toast or celery...combines butter and nuts excellently"
Almond, pecan, walnut nut butter

Marilee C.

Almond Pecan Walnut

Mind = Blown

"I've tried various nut butters over the years, but almost all of them have left me disappointed and unsatisfied; that streak ended today. I picked up this smaller jar at work last evening and HOLY MOLY! These folks have cracked the nut butter da vinci code. Not only is this the best nut butter I've ever had, I'm supporting a local VT business. I don't think you'll be disappointed with this product nor do I think the recipient of such a wonderful gift will be either!"
Crunchy Cacao Nib and Coffee Nut Butter

Molly M.

Crunchy Cacao Nib & Coffe Nut Butter

Love this Pepita butter.

"I tried this from a local store in the Adirondack’s and fell in love with it. Have not tried the others yet but this is so good on slices of apple. Very tasty and healthy for a snack."
Sunflower Pepita Crunch Nut Butter

Teresa V.

Sunflower Pepita Crunch

Nut butter from maple, walnut, pecan and cashew


Join our list for weekly updates, recipes, deals, and more!

What inspired MIXED UP

It all began in January 2020, just before my last semester at the University of Vermont. A local store discontinued my father's newfound nut butter, and as a passionate home cook, I offered to recreate it for him. He had his doubts, but it was love at first bite. This nut butter became his New Favorite. Months later, COVID-19 arrived, my post-graduate job offer fell through, and we officially founded Mixed Up Nut Butter in May.
At Mixed Up Nut Butter, we don’t discriminate. Sure, have your nut butter with jam between two slices of bread (which we love), but there’s a whole world of flavor combinations out there! Don’t limit yourself. Replace any nut butter or tahini, with ours in any recipe. That means you can use it in baked goods, dressings, sauces, or paired with your favorite cheese and wine. See our recipes page for more ideas!
We hope our nut butter leads you and your customers to live healthier lives, just as it does for us at Mixed Up Nut Butter.
— Kent Arnold, Co-Founder at Mixed Up Nut Butter

Frequently Asked Questions







What type of tree nuts do you use in your nut butters?
Across our nut butters, we use at least two types of nuts: almonds, pecans, cashews, and walnuts.
Are your nut butters vegan, paleo and Whole30 friendly!
Yes, they are!
I can't eat gluten, can I still eat your nut butters?
Generally, yes. We do not use any gluten-containing ingredients, and have some customers with Celiac's Disease who enjoy our products. Since we produce our products in a shared facility, there may be other producers that use gluten-containing ingredients in their products.
What about palm oil, dairy and other additives?
Our products are free from palm oil, refined oils, refined sugars, gluten, dairy, GMOs, flavorings, artificial preservatives, and other additives
What's the shelf life of your nut butters?
Our nut butters have a shelf life of 12 months after they're jarred. This date can be found on the bottom of the jar.
Do I need to refrigerate my nut butter after opening?
Although refrigeration can extend the freshness of your nut butter, refrigeration is not required. Some of our products may become temporarily un-spreadable if placed in the fridge or another cool area. It depends on the ingredients in each one.
How should I store my nut butter?
Our nut butters should be stored in a cool and dry place to maintain freshness.
Why is there a layer of oil on top of my nut butter?
Since our nut butters are natural and don't contain emulsifiers or palm oil, natural oil separation will occur, but don't sweat it! Just stir well and enjoy. We find a chopstick or fork works best to keep your stirring experience clean!
Are all your nut butters peanut free?
YES! Our nut butters are made from tree nuts only, no peanuts. Since we produce our products in a shared facility, there may be other producers that use peanuts in their products.
Where do you source ingredients from?
When we can, we source our ingredients locally from Vermont and the USA, but certain ingredients aren't available in the United States due to climatic differences, such as cashews, vanilla bean, and cacao-based ingredients. We proudly use California-grown almonds and walnuts, Texas-grown pecans, Vermont-harvested maple sugar, and New England-roasted coffee.
Where can I find the nutrition facts of your nut butters?
Find the nutrition facts of each of our nut butters printed on the jar, and on their product pages by viewing their additional photos.
What do I use your products with?
You can check out our recipes page  to find our favorite dishes and snacks you can make with our nut butters. We post only the best-tasting recipes for each flavor - walnut, pecan, cashew, almond, and seed nut butter. You can also follow us on Instagram or TikTok, where we share video tutorials of our favorite nut butter recipes.


Where can I purchase your nut butters?
We sell here on our site, in retailers throughout the USA, and at events and markets during the summer and fall.
Do you offer discounts?
Yes, we do! You can join our email list here [link] to get 10% off for signing up, plus we will send you email-exclusive deals.
How can I order Mixed Up Nut Butter Wholesale for my store?
Please look at our wholesale page for more information.
Can I find your products in local retail stores?
Visit our store locator to find us in a store near you. Call for availability before visiting.
Can I sign up for a subscription to receive regular deliveries?
We currently only have a rewards program. You earn points with every purchase and redeem your points to get discounts for future purchases.
How can I stay updated on promotions and discounts?
Sign up to our newsletter here [link].
Do you have a refer-a-friend or referral program?
Yes, we do! You'll gain access by joining our rewards program. Apply for our affiliate program to earn a 10% commission on every purchase made using your affiliate link.
Where can I learn more about the health benefits of your nut butters?
Check out our blog [link]! We frequently share educational resources related to the health benefits of our products.


How long does it typically take to process and ship an order?
Generally, it takes up to 2 business days to ship orders.
What are your shipping rates?
We offer flat-rate shipping within the USA ranging from $5-$10 depending on your region. Orders of $50+ ship free.
Can I change my shipping address after placing an order?
If you need to make any changes to your shipping address, contact us with your order number and updated shipping address.
Do you ship internationally?
Currently, we do not ship internationally.
How do I track my order?
After placing an order, you'll receive your tracking information via email or text once it has been fulfilled. You can also create an account to check the status of your orders in one place.
What should I do if my package is damaged during shipping?
Contact us with your order number and photos of the damaged shipment and we'll send you a replacement.
Do you offer free shipping?
We offer free shipping on orders $50+.
Do you ship to P.O. boxes or APO/FPO addresses?
We do not.


What is your refund policy for unused and unopened products?
If the product is unused or unopened, we will send you a return label. Once we receive the items and determine that they're sellable, we will issue a full refund.
How do I request a refund for a product that I am not satisfied with?
Contact us with your order number.
Can I still receive a refund if I've opened the packaging but didn't like the product?
Yes, we can. But first, we encourage you to ensure you've thoroughly stirred the product, and that you've allowed it to come to room temperature before tasting. Next, if you're still not satisfied, share it with friends and family. Then, contact us.
Do you offer refunds for products purchased through third-party retailers?
We do not. If you had a less than stellar experience with our product purchased elsewhere, contact us with where you purchased it from, a description of what you felt wasn't right, and any photos (if applicable). Then, we'll see how we can make it right. :)
Can I exchange my nut butter for another flavor?
We do not accept exchanges.


How can I reach your customer support?
Visit our contact page or talk to our chatbot in the bottom left corner.
Can I contact you through social media channels?
Yes, you can message us on Instagram or Facebook.
How do I get in touch via email or phone number?
Visit our contact page or text (802)448-2838.