Skip to content
Pause slideshow
Play slideshow
$50+ ORDERS SHIP FREE
Free Shipping on Orders $50+ After Discounts
CHOOSE EXPEDITED SHIPPING FOR XMAS
CHOOSE EXPEDITED SHIPPING FOR XMAS DELIVERY
Mixed Up Foods
Shop
Holiday
Find Near You
Online
All products
Glass Jars (NEW)
Regular Jars
Half Jars
Bundles & Deals
Jams
Gift Cards
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Bliss" - Maple, Walnut & Pecan Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
About
Our Story
Contact
Events
Recipes
Reviews
Earn
Rewards
Give $5, Get $5
Affiliate Program
* Holiday Collection *
Search
Account
0
Cart
.
.
.
Site navigation
Close
Search
Search
Cancel
Goes great with
Quick shop
Add to cart
Nut Butter + Jam Gift Box
$45
00
$45.00
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
Mini Jam Bundle – Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry
$11
99
$11.99
"Close (esc)"
Add order note
Close
Your cart is currently empty.
Shop
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Shop
View all
icon-chevron
Holiday
icon-chevron
Find Near You
icon-chevron
Online
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Online
View all
icon-chevron
All products
icon-chevron
Glass Jars (NEW)
icon-chevron
Regular Jars
icon-chevron
Half Jars
icon-chevron
Bundles & Deals
icon-chevron
Jams
icon-chevron
Gift Cards
icon-chevron
About
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
About
Our Story
icon-chevron
Contact
icon-chevron
Events
icon-chevron
Recipes
icon-chevron
Reviews
icon-chevron
Earn
icon-chevron
Expand submenu
Earn
Rewards
icon-chevron
Give $5, Get $5
icon-chevron
Affiliate Program
icon-chevron
* Holiday Collection *
icon-chevron
All Butters
8 products
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Availability
In stock
(8)
Out of stock
(0)
Price
.
.
.
.
Filter
8 products
Sort
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Large
Small
List
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Bliss" - Maple, Walnut & Pecan Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Maple Creemee" - Vermont Maple, Cashew, and Pecan Nut Butter with Vanilla Bean - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"Mud Season" - Crunchy Cacao Nib & Coffee Nut Butter - 7.5 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"The New Favorite" - Almond, Pecan, and Cashew Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
"The High Bar" - Almond, Pecan, and Walnut Nut Butter - 8 oz
$14
95
$14.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
Everyday Seed Butter: Sunflower Pepita Crunch - 8 oz
$9
95
$9.95
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
Everyday Seed Butter: Sunflower Pepita Crunch - 3.8 oz
$5
99
$5.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick shop
Add to cart
Nut Butter + Jam Gift Box
$45
00
$45.00
"Close (esc)"
Recently viewed
"Close (esc)"
icon-chevron
"Close (esc)"
All Butters