Reviews

Based on 57 reviews
93%
(53)
7%
(4)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
Delicious

We received a sample pack for Christmas. My son is completely sold. Maple varieties are his favorite!

amazing!

I bought a small pot of this at Kiss the Cook on Church St. and am immediately looking for more! Mud Season is the most delicious peanut butter I have ever tasted.

Yummy

Receive a sample pack for Christmas. Love them all. Especially the Maple Bliss walnut pecan and cashew. Saw this flavor when I came on-site to reorder it and now will be getting this also.

As a "Non-Peanut Butter" eater....

I very rarely eat peanut butter; it basically has to be baked into something. When I tried the sample of Maple Bliss in Stowe, VT, I was SOLD and immediately purchased 3 jars. I blissfully ate it on my rice cakes every day and (foolishly) gave one of my jars to a co-worker. Even though I made someone else happy, I certainly rued the day when I ran out of my own! I quickly logged into the website and ordered more jars which arrived just a few days later. Such speedy service and so happy to have found this delightful delicacy. I'm a convert for sure and find that any other "specialty" peanut butters don't come near the quality/taste/mouth feel/yumminess that I'm getting from mixedupnutbutter.com.

Incredible and unexpected!

The incredible flavor of coffee and chocolate is such an unexpected flavor explosion! I love the other flavors but this one stands out as exceptional.

Heavenly

I absolutely love this nutbutter. The flavor is amazing and t once stirred the butter and oils stay blended. Amazing!

Maple heaven!

The maple butters are the absolutely best! Too tasty to eat any other way than it’s purest form, by the spoonful! Love the textures of these, too.

What a fantastic photo! Thank you :) Enjoy!

Delicious

Love the flavor of this, make sure you stir it up because everything settles at the bottom

Stir it up like Marley. Thanks, Shiv!

New favorite

This has become my new favorite!!!!

Simply the best. Thanks, Hirsch!

Bought this in Vermont for the first time

This nut butter was so good I had to order some as soon as I got home. It's like eating candy! See now I can add a See now I can add a photo

Hirsch, thank you for your support! It looks like you have a nicely stocked pantry

Fabulous

We love The High Bar. It is a great alternative in our peanut-free house.

Elizabeth, thank you for your review! :)

Yummy!

So delicious and no added sugar! Highly recommend!!

Rochel, Thank you so much for your review! :) It's nice to have a delicious and healthy snack around.

L
Almond, Pecan, and Cashew Nut Butter - "The New Favorite"
Linda and Peter Dytrych (Roswell, US)
Extremely tasty; great flavor combination

Love all Vermont products; so much love put into this line of nut butters. I did have a nice email exchange with the owner. Generally I would like to see the consistency a bit more spreadable like peanut butter vs. more liquidy as it is now. I realize, however, that all the new nut butter products clump on the bottom and have to be stirred very well; just this product is liquidy even with the bit of solidity at the bottom. Would not avoid buying from this company, however. Again, the flavors are interesting and unique.

Extremely tasty; great flavor combination

Love all Vermont products; so much love put into this line of nut butters. I did have a nice email exchange with the owner. Generally I would like to see the consistency a bit more spreadable like peanut butter vs. more liquidy as it is now. I realize, however, that all the new nut butter products clump on the bottom and have to be stirred very well; just this product is liquidy even with the bit of solidity at the bottom. Would not avoid buying from this company, however. Again, the flavors are interesting and unique.

L
Coconut, Cashew, and Pecan Nut Butter - "Coconut Flurry"
Linda and Peter Dytrych (Roswell, US)
Extremely tasty; great flavor combination

Love all Vermont products; so much love put into this line of nut butters. I did have a nice email exchange with the owner. Generally I would like to see the consistency a bit more spreadable like peanut butter vs. more liquidy as it is now. I realize, however, that all the new nut butter products clump on the bottom and have to be stirred very well; just this product is liquidy even with the bit of solidity at the bottom. Would not avoid buying from this company, however. Again, the flavors are interesting and unique.

Love it, except for the coffee bean or cocoa pieces

This is a wonderful combination of cocoa and coffee flavors; my only issue is that there are pieces of hard shells in it. If it were completely pulverized, it would make it a 5 star. Just a bit annoying to be crunching it as you consume it.

Yummmmm

Tastes just like a maple creemee

I love it! It is my new favorite nut butter!

The Greatest Thing Since Actual Peanut Butter

I first tasted this at a Farmers Market in Burlington, VT. And now have it shipped in bulk to HAWAII!. It's a great spread to put on apples and other fruits... especially if you have kids. Why can I only give 5 stars?

I changed my mind

THIS is my favorite now. So good. Spoons only. too good to put on anything.

Soooo much YUM!

I have enjoyed all of the nut butters made by Mixed Up Nut Butter, and this newest offering is no exception. It’s depth of flavor will lend itself to many ways to enjoy it. French toast, maybe a dollop on a s’more… swoon!

Vivian, thank you so much! We're big s'mores fans too. :)

Great stuff

Yummy and unique. Great in a smoothie or on French toast. Not you’re average nut butter

The french toast idea is genius! Thanks for sharing your review, Maria. :)

amazing

I love the taste the texture is wonderful. great on toast, on crackers..a great dessert as such..

Thank you for your review, Diane!

Delicious

Bought this product in November and am slowly making my way through the jar, enjoying every delicious bite. I look forward to sampling and enjoying all 4 jars of my recent purchase. Can't wait til your new product hits the market! Am anxious to learn what you have in store. Good luck!

Rachel, we're glad you're enjoying the goods! We have a few new products brewing. Stay tuned. Thank you!

Truly such a natural, great taste that I cannot get enough of!

There's never enough! Thank you for your review